Missouri’s Scope of Practice Wars

Missouri is one of the most restrictive states in the U.S. for scope of practice for APRNs (advance practice nurses). Yet, parts of Missouri are greatly underserved by primary care practitioners (PCPs). Although we have what might be best described as a nationwide shortage of PCPs, the Center for Studying Health System Change has documented that that the shortage is particularly acute in southern and western states. 

So, it could be worse here in Missouri.  But, it could be better.  And it might get much worse with the addition of a further 17 million Americans moving into insured status under the Affordable Care Act.

If we are stressed to provide PCP services in rural Missouri under the status quo (where an estimated 13 counties have only a CRNA — Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetist– to provide anesthesia services) what will happen if we expand Medicaid?  Is this a reason not to expand Medicaid? 

I sometimes hear this advanced as what I call the "we can't do it, so we shouldn't even try" argument, as if provider supply were immutable, immune from market forces.  PCP supply is so tight — the argument goes —  the whole system might collapse of its own weight if we further expand the pool of those seeking services.

This argument in favor of a rationing system based on grandfathering in the previously insured leaves me non-plussed.  Yet, it is a argument with considerable purchase in some health care reform debate circles.  It is, after all, the thinking behind widely discussed proposals to repeal the ACA but retain the provisions extending family health insurance coverage to children of insured families until the age of 26. 

The rationale — accident of birth, consanguinity or affinitity as a preference for insured status – seems to me to be close to arbitrary. The rationale for favoring employer based health insurance is in rewarding valued employees, not their 25 year old married, independent tax status, employed elsewhere offspring.

Similarly, the argument that Missouri not confront head on its primary care provider shortage as a form of health care rationing also seems arbitrary.

Scope of practice regimens — including Missouri's restrictive collaborative practice requirements restricting phsycians-CRNA collaboration to a 3:1 ration– are not accidents of nature or, even, next best systems thrown together in a world of limited resources.  They are programmatically designed to restrict the provision of  PCP services by APRNs in Missouri.  This they do very well.

Whether the solution to the PCP shortage is to loosen scope of practice constraints on APRNs or to increase PCP phsyician supply, we might best start by owning the problem and owning our own role in creating the problem.

 

 

One comment

  1. Start from a shortage of PCPs by the end of the 1970s / early 1980s. (I suspect earlier; I remember my 96%-WhitenotLatino home town advertising for GPs by the time I left Junior High.)
    We have had 30+ years of subsidizing specialist (effectively at the expense of PCPs) from the largest payer for health-care services.
    We have had twenty years (1994) since doctors–especially PCPs– learned their future payments from the =other= source (private insurers) were going to be reduced significantly.
    PPACA addresses the first imbalance some, shifting payments back toward PCPs. But the “new equilibrium” won’t come quickly.
    The “Northern Exposure” solution doesn’t work well for citizens, but it’s got real potential for overseas MDs. Given that as the other option, I suspect APRNs (and especially NPs) would become the legislature’s preference.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s